Booksta || Twitter || Goodreads || StoryGraph || 25+ Book Discord
ARC book review time! Today I have a spoiler-free review of the much anticipated Carrie Soto Is Back from Taylor Jenkins Reid. I’ve been slowly whittling down my list of outstanding ARC books and doing an excellent job of not requesting any more until my current TBR pile is gone.
Thank you to Random House Publishing Group – Ballantine and NetGalley for an ARC copy in exchange for my honest review.
I think TJR has established that she can tell a pretty epic story. A lot of her books center around strong women, their lives, loves, and pitfalls. Carrie Soto is no exception to that rule. The tl;dr version of this review could easily be boiled down to: Are you interested in reading about someone’s tennis career or not?
PLOT
Carrie Soto isn’t just great at tennis; she’s the greatest of.all.time. And she has all the records to prove it. Trained by her father who is a former champion himself, Carrie blitzes through the tennis ranks capturing every title along the way. By the time she retires, Carrie is indisputably the best but also faces a lot of public backlash for her lack of humility and fiercely competitive playing style. Not that she cares.
But Carrie doesn’t get to enjoy her retirement long. Six years after, she finds herself watching the stunning Nicki Chan make a run for her Grand Slam record. Never one to be beaten, this prompts Carrie to come out of retirement for one more run at reclaiming her title under the tutelage of her father, just like the old days. It won’t be easy though with the media not forgetting or forgiving “The Battle Axe” persona she’s built, a distraction from her past, and Carrie’s own body slowing her down. But not of that has ever stopped her before.
Characters
I personally wasn’t as much of a fan of Carrie as I was of Evelyn Hugo, for example. I have to commend TJR for creating complex, flawed characters though. Her characters feel real and multidimensional. Yes, Carrie can come across a bit cold, especially in the beginning of the book, but as with other TJR books you start to understand the characters more and more as the story progresses.
Spoiler-Free Review
I wanted to like this book more than I did. I was hoping that the tennis aspect would be more of a backdrop than a focal point of the story. In Evelyn Hugo, for example, you get a good picture of Evelyn’s Hollywood movie career background. You learn about her rise to fame and things that happen throughout her career. Still, the focal point of the story was more centered around Evelyn’s personal life, her relationships, and the Hollywood starlet part was sort of seamlessly weaved into that.
Be forewarned that Carrie Soto is not this way. The first 25% of the book is almost all just her career leading up to retirement. Various competitions she attends, opponents her and her father strategize against to beat, the particulars of specific tennis plays, a glimpse into her attitude in the public spotlight… and that’s about it. We’re talking roughly 100 pages of tennis competitions that all start blending together and feeling pretty repetitive.
The next 75% picks up a fair amount. We start getting a lot more from the story, seeing Carrie’s support system, including her relationship with her father, a friendship and a budding romance. While there’s still a ton of tennis action, as is to be expected, there’s also a lot of heartfelt writing that I’ve come to expect from TJR. I found myself still wanting to skim some of the tennis play talk, but it does get a lot better.
Another thing that may or may not affect you is the fact that Carrie’s father speaks in Spanish quite frequently. If you know Spanish or enough Spanish to get by, this may not be of concern to you at all. But just know that TJR does not translate this Spanish at all. If pausing your reading to google Spanish sentences doesn’t bother you, great! If that sounds like something that would take you out of the story or bother you, there’s your warning.
Overall, I think TJR tells a good story of perfection and self-acceptance. This isn’t one of my favorites of hers, but I think if you have interest in sports or competition you’ll find the first fourth of the book more palatable.
Recommended for:
• Fans of TJR’s storytelling style
• Readers with a special interest in sports and competition themes
• Readers who enjoy heartfelt lessons about self-realization